A football team in North London had the courage to dream. They won the ostentatious title of “The Invincibles” in 2003–04 after going a full Premier League season undefeated. It was legendary, the sort of story dads told their kids before bed. Then, however, an odd event occurred. Arsenal apparently concluded that winning the Premier League was a pointless endeavour and embarked on a two-decade journey of spectacular underachievement. And it’s been quite the adventure!
The Craft of Nearly
From that incredible 2003–04 campaign, Arsenal has perfected the art of “almost,” nearly competing with the best, nearly dominating Europe, nearly winning the league, and nearly retaining their top players. It’s amazing how a team with such a strong financial position and illustrious past can continually fall short at the most important times.
The cry, “This is our year!” has grown commonplace among fans, but it is quickly followed by a mid-season meltdown, an injury crisis, and, finally, the depressing acceptance of finishing in fourth place—until they began to miss it too. For a while, it appeared like Arsène Wenger was more proud of earning Champions League qualifying than real hardware, and the infamous term “fourth-place trophy” was created (Wilson, 2019).
A Farewell Present: Legends’ Departure
Seeing your finest players win titles elsewhere after selling them to competitors is the epitome of “we’re a top club.” Arsenal has refined this wonderful heritage. A number of players, including Samir Nasri, Alexis Sánchez, Robin van Persie, and Cesc Fàbregas, have frequently left the Emirates in pursuit of, well, success.
Van Persie’s move to Manchester United was especially lyrical. He came to Old Trafford and won the Premier League title right away after spending eight years at Arsenal with no wins at all (Taylor, 2013). He may have chuckled as he accepted his Premier League winning gold, murmuring, “So this is what ambition looks like.”
Hunting for Trophies in the Incorrect Forest
For a team that takes immense pride in its past, Arsenal has obligingly avoided expanding its collection over the past 20 years. Let’s face it, the FA Cup is the football equivalent of receiving a participation medal, even though it has been a reassuring consolation reward.
The Cup of Carabaos? Let’s not even talk about that. To avoid damaging their image of never winning, Arsenal has advanced to the finals (Harris, 2022).
Europe? That is a more serious joke. The only other occasion Arsenal ever came close to winning a European championship was when they lost to Barcelona in the closing minutes of their Champions League final in 2006 (Smith, 2006). Since then, there has been a combination of humiliating losses, early departures, and the sporadic Europa League campaign that unavoidably fails.
Owners: The Quiet Participants in Failure
Arsenal has had Stan Kroenke, but other teams have profited from ambitious ownership prepared to make significant financial investments in success. The American entrepreneur, popularly referred to as “Silent Stan,” has shown the type of leadership that gives the appearance of vitality to a tortoise. Arsenal has changed under his leadership from a team that won titles to one that celebrates being in the top four as though they had won the Champions League (Jones, 2021).
Kroenke obviously knows how to win, as evidenced by the fact that his previous endeavours, such as the NFL’s LA Rams and the NBA’s Denver Nuggets, have won their respective titles. However, he doesn’t appear to want to employ that magic recipe with Arsenal.
The Highest Price for the Lowest
The devotion of Arsenal supporters is so strong that they are prepared to pay the highest Premier League ticket costs for a team that only brings heartache. Hundreds of people swarm the Emirates Stadium every year to see their team demand exorbitant prices for mediocre performances. It’s a very remarkable accomplishment. It would be ideal if the team’s pricing strategy aligned with its on-field goals (Mitchell, 2023).
Hope or More of the Same for the Future?
Arsenal has made some progress under Mikel Arteta. Even though they nearly challenged for the title in 2022–2023 and 2023–2024, they ultimately lost. It’s similar to seeing a sad play when you know how it will end but are drawn in by the drama.
What comes next, then? Another January disaster, another promising start, and yet another year of Arsenal supporters telling themselves, “Next season will be different.” Will it, though? If Arsenal doesn’t operate like a real European powerhouse by making wise investments, retaining its finest players, and holding its owners to higher standards, the team will continue to perform mediocrely.
At least they have the FA Cup till then. There is no doubt that a participation medal is gleaming in its display case.
References
- Harris, J. (2022). Arsenal’s League Cup Failures: A Historical Review. The Guardian.
- Jones, P. (2021). Stan Kroenke and the Business of Arsenal. Financial Times.
- Mitchell, L. (2023). The Economics of Football: Arsenal and Ticket Prices. BBC Sport.
- Smith, R. (2006). Champions League Final: Arsenal’s Heartbreak in Paris. ESPN.
- Taylor, D. (2013). *Van Persie: From Arsenal to Premier
The Love of the Game 